Mariah Yeater Caught Texting Friend That Justin Bieber Isn’t The Father

November 17th, 2011 // 78 Comments

“Shh.. shh… I know you wanted to be a Jonas baby, but them’s got the gay, y’all.”

While it was starting to look like Mariah Yeater‘s withdrawn paternity suit against Justin Bieber was about to result in a nice, quiet little payoff, TMZ has obtained text messages Mariah sent to a friend just yesterday asking him to delete texts from her mom that name the real father of her baby. On top of that, she also promises the friend a cut of the money. Whoops:

In the text, Yeater pleads for John to “ERASE ALL MESSAGES from my mom.” The text goes on to say that her mom sent John messages in the past, stating that baby Tristyn was fathered by Robbie — an ex-boyfriend.
She then goes on to talk about giving John money if he cooperates: “Ill kick u when we get paid.”

And TMZ has seen many other texts between Mariah and John. In one text, Mariah writes, “[John], would you please stress to Robbie how important it is for him to be in his son’s life?..” Apparently, Mariah forgot about this text, because she didn’t ask John to erase it.

Justin Bieber’s lawyers are now in possession of the texts which pretty much wraps this story up except let’s take a moment to reflect on the innocent, helpless victim in all this: Maury Povich. Somewhere he sits sulking in a fisherman’s hat and raincoat, harpoon discarded on the floor. This was to be his White Whale. His Swan Song…

R.I.P. Maury.

Photo: Bauer-Griffin


  1. Sliver

    Uh-oh….but that baby does have some Biebs-like eyes.

  2. She can sue Bieber for giving her herpes instead. That has to be the reason she didn’t cover up whatever is going on on her upper lip.

  3. Poop head

    I think Colin Mochrie’s the father.

  4. Mariah Yeater Son Tristyn Justin Bieber
    Commented on this photo:


  5. Mariah Yeater Son Tristyn Justin Bieber
    Commented on this photo:

    Stress brings out the herps. What could she possibly be stressed about? Hmmmmm.

  6. Mariah Yeater Son Tristyn Justin Bieber
    Commented on this photo:

    Give mommy a kiss!

  7. Leave it to the press… another ridiculous future reality star in the making.

    • TomFrank

      I suspect we’ll find out in a few days’ time that she came up with this plan only after MTV rejected her application to be one of the next Teen Moms.

      “But I was 19 when I got pregnant!”
      “But you’re 20 now, and that’s not ‘teen’ anymore. It’s Teen MOM, not Teen Skank. Also…how do I put this…your face is more Oxygen than MTV.”
      —How that went.

    • cc

      God I hope not. She might just be a bigger piece of shit than Kim K.

  8. Jake Zero

    well, no matter who the baby daddy be, keep him the hell away from Jerry Sandusky.

    • Peter Paul Dick

      Don’t give this attention whore any ideas. You know she’d rent her kid out to Jerry the Child Molester if she could sell the exclusive photos to a tabloid.

  9. forrest gump

    BeeWeeBieber the father?
    ………..she really said that?

    hahahahahahahahaha, justin himself just stopped wearing diapers for a few weeks now………..

    • What satisfaction do you gain by insulting Justin like that? Famous or not, he’s a young adult with feelings.
      I dare you to say that on a stage in front of hundreds of people to Justin’s face.
      (Sorry, but I’m sick of these immature comments.)

  10. Mariah Yeater Son Tristyn Justin Bieber
    Any Guy
    Commented on this photo:

    the herps AND yellow teeth? what a catch! i hate lawyers, but in this case – sue that ugly bitch into the stone age. she’s gonna have to sell that baby on the black market when this is all said and done. congrats bitch.

  11. AlbertaGuy

    Haha, Looks like her buddy John cashed in! Now she knows how it feels to get fucked over by someone looking for money.

  12. wb

    Nice herpes there. She and octomom should get together to discuss parenting.

  13. roughly 99.9%

    So what, they discover emails? She wants Bieber to be the father. She’s establishing plans for a brighter future for her child. What’s WRONG with that? Sometimes judges have ordered some men who are not biological to pay anyway. Look at how cute the kid is what guy in his right mind wouldn’t want to pay? Bieber can afford it, beside by paying his street cred as a playa will go to the roof…

    • KumaTenshi

      What the fuck is wrong with you?? What’s WRONG with wanting someone who is NOT the father to be the father?? Are you fucking kidding me???

      That’s not establishing plans, that’s being a dumb fucking cunt. And this idiot finally got called out and shown for the stupid twat she is. Good riddance.

    • roughly 99.9%

      You want this kid to rob you when he grows up? With the economic security Bieber will be providing; this kid will have a better chance at a better life. You’re also not taking her emotional pleas into account. She believes she had an encounter with the young star; so youre obviously indifferent to her feelings. Not everyone is cut out for a 9 to 5.

      • nastytxblues

        Uh…so let me get this straight. You think it’s totally fine that she try to extort money from Justin Bieber because she has a demented fantasy that he is the father? And it’s ok for her to do this because the economy is bad and she’s too lazy to work? Please tell me you’re trolling.

      • m

        anyone who “isn’t cut out for a 9 to 5″ deserves to be living in a cardboard box on the side of the road. why should even an irritating little tweenybopper who thinks he can sing have to pay her just cuz he’s rich and she’s a lazy slut???

      • Shinichi

        That’s quite a bad excuse for something called attempted fraud. If she isn’t cut out for a 9 to 5 and provide for her own child then she shouldn’t have children in the first place.

    • roughly 99.9%

      Hey Txblues? Youre just throwing that “trolling” thing in the air to see where it lands? Everyone that’s vs abortion should sympathize with her plea. What ever happen to no child left behind? I thought we were a village?

    • Richard C.Mongler

      Troll score: 9/10. Congrats!

    • roughly 99.9%

      There you go. Each time I don’t agree with a point of view im going to label them a “troll” what ever that means.

    • hahaha

      and I was like crazy crazy crazy ooooohhhhh

  14. Honest to God, this chick has got to be dumber than a bag of hammers. How the fuck did she think this had a snowball’s chance in hell of working? The only way it could have had less chance of working was is she said it was Flava Flav’s kid.

    • MC Hammer

      Hey, fuck you man.

    • me

      Well it seems to have worked… See those pics up there? She got paid for them. You’re talking about her, that will get her an interview in plenty of magazines. She will get paid for those as well.
      She doesn’t seem so dumb to me…

      • Well, I guess it depends on what her expected outcome was… if she actually expected Bieber to pay some sort of ongoing child support, then she’s an idiot. If her goal was to end up in the media and make money that way, then I’ll concede that she may be more savvy than I gave her credit for.

      • Though, in my defence, life experience has led me to believe most of humanity barely has enough neurons firing to maintain a pulse and continue breathing unaided.

    • dinkster

      I hope The Bieb countersues and crushes her worthless ass.

  15. juicyfruit

    Poor kid having such a tramp for a mother.

  16. Venom

    Well she is screwed now.

  17. Mariah Yeater Son Tristyn Justin Bieber
    Commented on this photo:

    Herpes, yellow teeth, chompin on a piece of gum….trashy skank.

  18. Dude of Dudes

    This chick has a bitchin future in stock photography.

  19. Arkon

    Was only a matter of time before this collapsed under her. Everything she’s done since the start of this paternity thing has been sketchy. No wonder her lawyers bailed at the first hint of a counter-suit.

    Too bad, if Bieber was the father it would have been funny.

  20. Mariah Yeater Son Tristyn Justin Bieber
    Commented on this photo:

    That poor, sweet baby. What a life lies ahead for him.

  21. Me think

    Those text still doesn’t prove that Justin isn’t the father. When were those text sent? It could have been when she wasn’t sure who the father was. Maybe she still isn’t sure, and it’s possible that she and Bieber did have a sexual encounter. In this day and age, I doubt any woman would be this crazy to fabricate this to that extent if their wasn’t a pinch of truth or possibility somewhere. Bieber just needs to take the DNA test, make public and get this over with, if not, I’m convinced there was a cover up.

    • TomFrank


      • Jessesgirl

        Why should no burden of proof be on Beiber’s side? It’s pretty obvious he’s a little shit who thinks he can do anything and get away with it and besides he has as good a motive for trying to do a cover up as this chick would have for inventing this yarn. Or is something true just because a disney pop brat says it?

  22. tom

    Where do those photos come from ? Did she hired a PR agency ?

  23. m

    she obviously already got money off this crap, so whatever she wins to some extent. however, everyone involved in this was completely stupid to not hear of her claim and get some DNA the hell out of that bieber thing to prove either it is or is not his baby ASAP. clearly he had sex with her when she says he did or he would have said “heeelllll no it’s not mine, here’s a cheek swab to prove it!” 5 seconds after she made her claim.

  24. skuddles

    Oh oh, someone’s got the herpes… and does this girl not wash her hair? She looks wired – and grubby.

  25. Do Freebird

    Fish -
    Please tell us the company you work for didn’t go out and buy all these photos.

  26. No Beiber fan but this story I knew was bullshit. nest BS we will hear. “Demi Lovato made lesbian love to me in treatment.” At least that story will be fap worthy.

    I also think Demi’s “relationship” with WV is also questionable at best.

  27. Mariah Yeater Son Tristyn Justin Bieber
    Commented on this photo:

    She shouldn’t be kissing on that sweet little baby with her nasty herpes infested upper lip..this girl is disgusting.

  28. Mariah Yeater Son Tristyn Justin Bieber
    Commented on this photo:

    What’s with the engagement ring?

  29. Mariah Yeater Son Tristyn Justin Bieber
    Commented on this photo:

    Poor kid.

  30. Mariah Yeater Son Tristyn Justin Bieber
    Commented on this photo:

    Even the kid is thinking, “Bitch be crazy.”

  31. Bria

    Jesus Christ on a bike! This is ridiculous already! Get a paternity test and lets be DONE!!!

  32. Mariah Yeater Son Tristyn Justin Bieber
    Commented on this photo:

    Nice herpes lip.

  33. Tunacrab

    Tristyn? Seriously? It would be awful enough on a girl, but a boy’s name? Jesus, single white mothers are now worse than black women when it comes to giving their spawn terrible names… simply awful, cutesy, “creatively” spelled names. remember when every knocked up white chick under 25 named their sons “Caleb” or “Kaleb?” I hope Tristyn isn’t the new trend.

    Tristyn… Poor kid. He’s gonna have a fucked up life.

    What happened to, John, Mike, Joe, Steve and James?

  34. You know… if Bieber doesn’t want her, I’ll fuck her for him.

  35. Dr Ha-Ha

    Hold it up a second.
    After everything the other day said this was going underwraps, so no matter what the outcome was we’d supposedly never find out, now all of a sudden there’s text messages ‘just yesterday’ being sent to allow us to ‘really know’ the truth? Who is to say with the silence cone having come down, Bieber said “ok, it’s my kid, but now the public has to find out some way it isn’t, so send these false texts, and everyone wins. I keep my rep intact & you get the cash”.


  36. amy

    Let me first start by saying if you are going to lie and say a celeb got you pregnant at least pick a cool one. Second she is after cash right? Can she still get the cash when she (assuming she is not a lier) got pregnant by statutorily rapping him? Since when does the victim have to pay? Also If she was a man and Biebs was a girl please believe Yeater would be in jail. Double standard much?

  37. ceece

    gold digging bitch

  38. Seun

    Come ad pse god

  39. This isn’t fair for baby, I know what she did was totally wrong, but he souldn’t sue her, She has a child. How else will she pay support for her baby? Justin is making a mistake about this. He will regret it when she cant support her family and is forced to put the baby up for adoption.

  40. Mariah Yeater Son Tristyn Justin Bieber
    Commented on this photo:

    how come she has a wedding ring?

  41. kate

    you are blessed with a beautiful baby Mariah ,and if what you are
    saying is a lie, you should be ashamed to use your innocent child like that, shame that your beautiful little boy should be used as beit.

  42. Mariah Yeater Son Tristyn Justin Bieber
    Flic Pipe
    Commented on this photo:

    i cant believe thats beibers baby!

  43. Mariah Yeater Son Tristyn Justin Bieber
    Commented on this photo:

    That baby looks like Justin

  44. Mariah Yeater Son Tristyn Justin Bieber
    Dr. Fill
    Commented on this photo:

    “Don’t worry my little meal ticket. I will teach you the ways of the trailer park. You’ll never have to pay for your meth if you listen to mommy. NOW START LOOKING LIKE JUSTIN BEIBER!!!”

  45. Mariah Yeater Son Tristyn Justin Bieber
    Commented on this photo:

    i really think its but why her she not even good looking

  46. Mariah Yeater Son Tristyn Justin Bieber
    Commented on this photo:

    she’s gross

  47. Mariah Yeater Son Tristyn Justin Bieber
    Commented on this photo:

    Meth mouth is a muh fugga!

Leave A Comment