She loves it when she has nuts in her mouth.
If a reviewer has sgined their name to a review they should be thanked in the acknowledgements, even if the advice were less than helpful. (That is, if you want to be politically astute). That the reviewer’s suggestions were constructive makes this gesture easier the review system worked here, yes? Trying to uncover someone’s intentions is wasted time, especially since this reviewer herself might not even know *why* she decided to sign the review. Or it is a typical act on her part. You can’t know until you ask.
Commenting as a Guest. Sign in or Join.