Minka Kelly and Leighton Meester Aren’t Making This Any Easier

January 25th, 2011 // 57 Comments

Here’s the often confused Leighton Meester and Minka Kelly at the premiere of The Roommate, and now that I see them together, I genuinely feel bad for thinking they look the same. It’s like equating one attractive woman to another attractive woman who happens to have a forehead the size of a windshield. That’s how eating disorders happen. Or unfortunate belt-sanding accidents. “I’ll show them who has a Leighton Meester head…” *BZZZZZZZZZZZZ*

Photos: Getty, Bauer-Griffin


  1. ick-abod

    silly lesbian, my forehead’s for loads.

  2. CptCreep

    I have an irresistible urge for a sandwich right now… weird…

  3. The Frito Bandito

    Hey Meester, you wanna fuck my seester? She’s a virgin an’ she looks like a movie star…

  4. Sen

    So which is the one in white?

    She’s hotter

  5. Leighton Meester Minka Kelly
    Commented on this photo:

    First of all…the movie looks stupid, secondly, why cast two girls who could pass as each other..that IS confusing.

  6. slappy magoo

    J. Lo & Julianne Moore earn college money, the early years.

    Do you think Leighton Meester’s dad ever gets sick of people asking if he’s the one that wrote “Broken Wings?”

  7. Ruby

    I still think they totally look alike. I know who’s who, but it doesn’t matter to me.

    • qwerty

      2-3 yrs ago it was impossible to tell them apart at times.
      Even now,when I google leighton meester first pic I get is Minka Kelly

  8. Leighton Meester Minka Kelly
    Commented on this photo:

    The fivehead doesn’t really bother me. I mean, I’ve sen those photos of her booty in lingerie…

  9. Leighton Meester Minka Kelly
    Commented on this photo:

    I’m still confused, who’s who? Anyway, id do em both at the same time, any time…

  10. Leighton Meester Minka Kelly
    Commented on this photo:

    It’s like when you dress twins in different colored shirts to tell them apart….please tell me some one’s man juice strayed and they’re related. Oh please please please.

  11. Leighton Meester Minka Kelly
    Commented on this photo:

    Minka Kelly acting like a drunk Jeremy Piven. That I didn’t see coming…

  12. hmna

    But they BOTH have fiveheads!

  13. Leighton Meester Minka Kelly
    Commented on this photo:

    I know I should be concentrating on other things but, what the fuck is wrong with Minka Kelly’s thumb?

    • Mandi

      Umm… nothing?

    • AnswerMan

      I think you’re looking at Leighton Meester’s thumb, not Kelly’s, and it looks like she’s got the same congenital condition with her thumbs as Megan Fox does (don’t remember what it’s called).

  14. Devo

    If you’d spent the better part of your career being compared to Blake Lively, you’d demand being casted with interchangeable actresses, too.

  15. Richard McBeef

    Kelly > Meester. Although Meester doesn’t have Jeter’s Original Brand Herpes®. At least not yet, eventually we will all have it.

  16. Macaulay Culkin

    I’m jerking off to Leighton Meester, Ya Filthy Animal

  17. Leighton Meester Minka Kelly
    Commented on this photo:

    So, basically this “new” movie is Single White Female…? Either way, those chicks are crazy hot and I’d bang both like a screen door in a hurricane.

  18. this is one of the few times when a pornstar look alike is actually better looking than the Hollywood actress (Tori Black > Leighton Meester)

  19. Parker

    I could slip my dick into her ass and never notice the Clear Channel sattelite dish forehead.

  20. Artimus

    Unless they’re promoting their new sex tape, I don’t care. Get off my Internets.

  21. They are both attractive, I like Miss Meester better cuz she looks like she is dirty in bed and you know it. Hey I know sluts, what can I say?

  22. terence

    dam these are my two favorites, i actually got both of them confused for minka kelly one time. id marry and pop kids in them if we were attracted to each other

  23. Eva

    I have to disagree, Leighton is way prettier whereas you could find lookalikes of this other chick in random strip joints.

  24. testington

    They’re both way hot. Leighton is prettier though. Minka looks a bit like a girl who took a picture of Leighton to a plastic surgeon…she just has that sort of artificial look about her.

  25. with these two who care. just flip a coin.

  26. abe vigoda's eyebrows

    which one is which? they are totally interchangeable.

  27. Mandi

    Fish, I love ya. But the fact that you could find anything wrong with Leighton Meester is… shocking. I’m not saying she’s the end all, be all, but jesus christ what level of perfection are you expecting?

  28. Mcrough

    So this is who Jeter pretends not pay attention to, when Kelly brings hot friends over? Bastard!

  29. Leighton Meester Minka Kelly
    Commented on this photo:

    Wow, she is amazing

  30. saywhat

    wait i dont get it, who is supposedly the ugly/big forehead one? i think they’re both gorgeous!

  31. anonym

    meester is definitely cuter.

    Kelly’s nose bridge is too wide.

    that said, both have equally high foreheads, and both are damn fuckable.

    I would eat both of them out, breakfast lunch and dinner.

  32. Leighton Meester Minka Kelly
    Commented on this photo:

    Leighton has Megan Fox thumbs. It always gets the hot ones.

  33. Anya

    if it wasn’t for gossip blogs I wouldn’t know who the hell these two were

  34. Hannibal King

    You’re right, they’re just making things harder…

  35. Dominick

    Minka FTW. End of story.

  36. wim

    (btw:only americans)

  37. Personification of the Gods that built Mount Olympus

    Kelly has a much better physique. Meester’s physique is shit. That said I’d fuck them both at the same time.

  38. Leighton Meester Minka Kelly
    one legged
    Commented on this photo:

    i wonder if she is friendly

  39. Leighton Meester Minka Kelly
    Commented on this photo:

    If you had masturbated with photos of both of them, you’d be able to tell the difference. They really don’t look much like each other.

  40. Leighton Meester Minka Kelly
    Commented on this photo:

    I wasn’t aware that they cast Leighton Meester as Pinhead in the new Hellraiser.

  41. Leighton Meester Minka Kelly
    Commented on this photo:

    hey baby!

  42. AtomManhattan

    Kelly does nothing for me. Just really not my type, seems too ‘ethnic’, like sh’e Mexican or some garbage like that, and I prefer pale white girls. Not that I’m racist or anything, but my dick sure as hell is.

    • juggernaut

      dude, i agree with you. not only does pale/pinkish skin look good, but the girl has to have blue eyes. brown eyes tells me the girl is only good for sex and you can never marry her because brown eyes remind me of feces and the last thing i’d want is to be stuck with a girl who has eyes that remind me of poop. anyway, blue eyes are the only girls i date and would ever consider marrying. megan fox is perfect looking. dakota fanning is perfect and has a lot of potential to be better. DIANE HEIDKRUGER is perfect! cameron diaz is nice, but if she didn’t have the cuban blood she probably wouldn’t have the messed up looking smile. and MALIN AKERMAN IS FLAWLESS! also, google Carli Banks, she looks good now, but her stuff from 2006-2007 is her at her best. i mean, she looks like she could be dakota fanning’s older sister with breasts. i’m actually friends with her. ANYWAY, i thought the film they were both in looked sexy, but it was pg13 and the only way i’m going to waste time watching these mediocre looking brown eyed girls, i’d have to see their nipples at least. i mean, i watched the preview and thought it’s maybe good for masturbating to, but the average looking girls don’t even get naked, therefore, i’d be better going to a club. seriously, there are actresses who look way better than these girls who are very comfortable getting nude in film and don’t think twice about it. why? because nudity in films is not bad and immoral. i just think it’s funny how 98% of european pornstars look like victoria secret models, if not better and they like it in the butt, they like girls and everything else. so, when i see terrible american actresses who have no training and aren’t that attractive not getting nude, i really lose respect for them. i’d say my favorite adult actresses(not porn) are Diane heidkruger, Malin Akerman and CARICE VAN HOUTEN! my favorite young actresses: dakota fanning. notice how non of these have brown eyes and all of them are great actors.

  43. Leighton Meester Minka Kelly
    Commented on this photo:

    You guys must be blind. The left one (minka) is so much prettier than walking forehead Leighton.

  44. Leighton Meester Minka Kelly
    Commented on this photo:

    I find Leighton prettier

  45. Leighton Meester Minka Kelly
    Commented on this photo:

    Poor Leighton looks uncomfortable.

Leave A Comment