Kenny From ‘Real World/Road Rules’ Allegedly Raped Tonya With A Toothbrush

October 28th, 2011 // 97 Comments

Welcome to another exciting edition of MTV is the goddamn devil. This time around, Real World/Road Rules castmember Tonya Cooley is suing MTV after producers allegedly stood by – and filmed – while castmates Kenny Santucci (above) and Evan Starkman raped her with a toothbrush. Although, in their defense, they did clean her vagina with it first which apparently is the polite thing to do in Shitbag Rapist Land. It’s practically the highest honor. TMZ reports:

Tonya Cooley filed the suit against MTV, Bunim/Murray Productions, Kenneth Santucci, Evan Starkman and others … claiming the two guys “took another male participant’s toothbrush and rubbed the toothbrush around plaintiff’s genitals, including rubbing her labia and inserting the toothbrush into plaintiff’s vagina.”
Cooley says it all happened while she was passed out cold … and cameras were rolling
Cooley says producers not only knew about the rape, they even replaced the toothbrush, but never told her what happened.

And if you’ve always suspected the entire set of Real World/Road Rules is a rape bonanza, surprise! The entire set of Real World/Road Rules is a rape bonanza. I’m sorry, “alleged” rape bonanza. And school of sexual assault dentistry:

The suit also claims female cast members were stripped of their bathing suits and that male cast members were encouraged by producers to “inappropriately touch female cast members’ bodies, including in intimate areas.”
Cooley alleges she and other cast members reported incidents of sexual abuse, but show honchos turned a blind eye.

Is anyone really surprised that the network that’s currently raping America with Jersey Shore and Teen Mom incorporates rape in all their programs? Because at this point they might as well just make a reality show called “Rape” and make rape look cool with pop music montages about rape. Now if you’ll excuse me, I need to field calls from MTV asking how I guessed their exact mid-season line-up right down to the rape. (Spoiler Alert: I tell them I “just took a rape in the dark.” Because they like rape.)

h/t Dlisted

Photos: Getty


  1. kj

    Uhm. What?

    • Louis CK

      I’m getting a rapey vibe off this chick.

    • shankyouverymuch

      ……. “took another male participant’s toothbrush and rubbed the toothbrush around plaintiff’s genitals, including rubbing her labia and inserting the toothbrush into plaintiff’s vagina.”…. Um, NO, I’m sorry but that’s not rape in any form or shape, that’s a funny good time! If you’re stupid enough to get so fucked up that you pass out at a club, bar, or on A SHOW! then YOU deserve what you get including the “tooth brush treatment” …… They should have pissed on her face & crapped in her mouth too…..
      I LOVE IT!

      • disgusted

        shankyouverymuch, I hope you don’t have any sisters, nieces, or females in your family that any of what you said would happen to. whether or not tonya is lieing, what you said should never happen to anybody….that is a horrible thing to say about anybody.

      • Artofwar

        …These allegations should be clarified. When someone so-called rapes you with a toothbrush in most cases it should not be considered rape—It should merely be considered someone’s way of telling you it is time to do something about whatever died in your malodorous cunt….Artofwar

      • Jennyjenjen

        Are you fucking kidding me? So, if you got wasted and one of your buddies shoved a toothbrush up your anus, that’s just a good time and you deserved it for getting in that condition? I suppose when a girl says no she really means yes, and she was “asking for it” wearing a low cut blouse or a short skirt? You are a degenerate who’s 1950′s logic shows how ignorant you are. Your last sentence shows how truly pathetic you are. How about a little less porn and self-stimulation and a little more attempting to interact in the real world. But I imagine all the rebuffs from the opposite sex have caused you to retreat to the arms of the internet. You’re very sick.

      • Actually no, according to the law that is indeed sexual assault.

        Also, you’re an absolutely disgusting human being.

      • seriously?

        the definition of rape is unwanted sexual penetration. this includes with fingers and objects. it is sick that you think that wouldnt be traumatic.

  2. OnTheRealThough

    Hmmm…When does this new challenge begin?

    God, these people are losers.

    • Trippin' Ballz

      Those pupils look a lil’ dinner plate for someone that just took a flash in the face.

      Just sayin’…

  3. CK

    Doesn’t really make sense that the producers would encourage this behavior. They wouldn’t be able to show any of it on TV. I call bullshit. I smell a money grubbing whore who is upset that there wasn’t a payout already for being a money grubbing whore. Welcome to the real world, whore.

    • Dude of Dudes


    • TetterkeT

      @CK: so do you think she’s a whore?

    • Rob

      Is it not possible that doing these antics off screen fuel the battles between roommates which sky rockets ratings? If it was just a show of people sitting around living with each other, no one would watch it. They intentionally put people into uncomfortable situations so things of this nature happen. Even if she is a money grubbing whore(who isnt on reality tv), it doesnt mean she deserved it.

      • CK

        @Rob. I see what you’re saying. I don’t doubt that produces incite and encourage fights by asking questions in interviews, and pushing for answers in confessionals that provoke conflict — prompting he said she said BS, but you are talking about a show with tons of cameras letting something this despicable just go on for ratings sake? Just doesn’t add up to me. That Tonya chick has tried to hook up with all those dudes and was rejected. She was kicked off for fighting. And just seems like a fame whore like all the others, and the money runs out quick when youre whorin it up bein famous. I can’t think that producers would not step in and interject in something like this. Hell, half of the producers I’ve met have been women, and you think a woman would allow this to go on? For ratings?

        I could be wrong, probably am. It’s all speculation anyways. Now, I got some whorin to do myself. peace!

      • So CK, you’re saying you have actually watched this drivel?

    • Brooke

      I agree with CK, it doesn’t make sense to film it. I could see some singular producer ass clown telling a guy “If you get a chance, poke her vadge with a toothbrush or something, that’ll really piss her off!” sometime when nobody was around, but I don’t see why or how they could film it as if it were a part of the show. MTV has low standards, but this is the sort of thing that would get them shut down (or at least this stupid show). Unless a disgruntled staff member was suicide bombing his own show, I think she is blowing some incident out of proportion or something. I’m guessing she didn’t say actual rape because there’s no sperm or stretch marks to prove it.

  4. Dude of Dudes

    Ive got some raw gemstones she can cut with that chin of hers.

  5. Tonya Cooley Real World Toothbrush Rape
    Commented on this photo:

    She-it… I’d force myself on her, too — she’s hot!

  6. Rough tell thales

    Road Rules still on air? That show sucked.

  7. Tonya Cooley Real World Toothbrush Rape
    Commented on this photo:

    Damn, she looks extra sexxy/slutty in this pic.

  8. just here for laughs

    Attention/fame whore.

    • Jesus, Brainiac, it goes without saying. That pretty much defines all celebrities, quasi-celebrities, pseudo-celebrities, and wanna-be-celebrities, and if it wasn’t for all of them, there would be no Superficial and nobody for us to poke fun at.

  9. TetterkeT

    She must be one dirty-ass bitch if they thought she needed a toothbrush in there.

  10. Mick

    Why couldn’t they use their penises like normal people.

    • For sure…if you’re going to get rousted for sexual assault you might as well us the right tool. You never know, she might like it and “forget” to call the badges.

      On the other hand, “raped with a toothbrush” does create better visuals.

  11. Anon

    MTV should just let her stick toothbrushes in those two dudes’ asses and call it even.

  12. Clarence Beeks

    The fact that the camera people and production crew would not stop that shit is awful.

    • EricLr

      This is MTV. Their crews are lower on the human evolution chart than the “Girls Gone Wild” scumbags. I’m just surprised they didn’t join in.

  13. TRON

    Tonya, one hot but crazy piece of ass from Walla Walla.

  14. jumpin_j

    Now if this was a Beavis & Buthead episode, whoa, that would be cool! huh uh huh huh.

  15. Hmm…so “rape” is not on the lay name for the plant Brassica Napus, and a subdivision of counties in Sussex England, but also a type of oral hygiene sexual assault?

    I learned something today.

  16. Cock Dr

    Something needs to bring down MTV’s reality TV programming & production division. Although I’m skeptical, this could be that thing. Burn it down.

    • cc


      I’d practically sell my soul to make that happen.

    • Dan

      Too many morons are giving them money Cock Dr.

      This will never happen.

      • Dan

        People also don’t just watch it to make fun of it. They actually mimic the behavior. They buy those stupid shirts and look like total d bags because they saw it on the show.

        And that is the problem, you make money by putting your shirts on the reality show and then selling them to fucking morons who would pay $70 for a printed tee shirt.

    • Frank Burns

      Sorry, its more likely they would simply turn it into more reality tv, following her through the court system and therapy, with Dr. Drew narrating.

  17. stratacat

    pics or gtfo.

  18. jim x

    To do all that while filming it on camera sure would be stupid.

    On the other side, everyone involved in creating this mindrot is probably morally and intellectually retarded.

    I’m going to have to wait for the court to rule on this one.

  19. Tonya Cooley Real World Toothbrush Rape
    Commented on this photo:

    Judging by the expression and that probing left hand, looks like she just discovered the gum disease known as GINGIVITIS.

  20. Donald Trump

    This dude has a terrible case of “gay face”. One of the worst I’ve seen in recent days. Poor thing.

  21. Cock of the..

    Don’t pass out in a house full of drunk men.
    Had to be said.

    • meh

      Thank you! Yes, you’re absolutely right. She’s lucky a toothbrush is all they stuck up there. We may have gone to the moon but we’re all still cave animals. If we can kill, rape, maim and torture and get away with it, we will and laugh while doing so.

    • What she said...

      I was thinking the exact same thing! Besides, isn’t Tonya like 40 years old now? It’s bad enough when college girls get wasted and pass out with a room full of drunk frat boys, but she’s a little old to still be learning this lesson. Have some dignity, Tonya! Getting a toothbrush up your vag is the least of your worries. Go get some help or find an AA place near your home, for God’s sake, and have some respect for yourself.

  22. anybody who watches these shows is a fucking retard.

  23. skunk

    fuck these stupid mtv shitty ass shows

  24. Thread is worthless without a link to the video.

    Besides it could have been his pencil thin dick down there and she was just thinking that she needed to brush her teeth after having sex with him. Add this mixture to her IQ and hence the confusion. As with many girls who regret their sexual promiscuity, it goes from brushing their teeth to making a rape charge.

    If there is a video and it is true however, the idiots doing it deserve all the plaque they are getting.

  25. Venom

    Sure Tonya sure. Wasn’t she on MTV like a 100 years ago? She has not moved on from there yet?

  26. Fester

    It’s a very sorry state of affairs when a whore can’t drink until she passes out in a house full of drunken assholes without expecting to have her pussy brushed.

  27. I’m sure a toothbrush is one of the least surprising items that’s been in the vagina of an MTV “reality” show star.

  28. Dan

    I am almost embarrassed to say that I find this incredibly funny. Not that rape is ever funny. But this for some reason is funny to me. I think it is the brushing of the labia or something – it sounds like some weird fetish.

    I am not sure what she expected to happen when she drank until she passed out in a house full of douche bag, assholes, but that doesn’t mean she deserved a toothbrush in the vagina.

    • Artofwar

      …But you are mistaken—RAPE is funny when put into the right context—-hell a joke about a retarded wheel chair bound four year old getting run-over by a bus can be funny when put into the right context….Artofwar

  29. spit cup

    I do believe the vitcim here is the toothbrush.

  30. Deacon Jones

    “Rape”. …..Please.

    Gotta love it when a cum dumpsters goes to her lawyer after the fact, rather than the cops.

  31. Drew

    Uh huh. Something tells me this slut that repeatedly drinks herself stupid, doesn’t say no to anything.

  32. Tonya Cooley Real World Toothbrush Rape
    Commented on this photo:

    Britney called from 2000, she wants her….everything back. Please give it to her, for everyone.

  33. Lord Invader

    Someone needs to face-rape Lindsay Lohan will a toothbrush.

  34. drunk again

    They should sell the toothbrush on Ebay … yummy yummy

  35. Tonya Cooley Real World Toothbrush Rape
    Commented on this photo:

    I’d let her violate my toothbrush.

  36. Tonya Cooley Real World Toothbrush Rape
    Commented on this photo:

    She’s not wearing her swimsuit. This must be the incident she was talking about.

  37. Uncle Phil

    A toothbrush on her vag? I knew those things had teeth.

  38. it had to be said

    Meh. She’s lucky they didn’t have access to a Sharpie.

  39. dontkillthemessenger

    I wish I could be more sympathetic. He should rape her forehead with a folding chair.

  40. twzzlrgirl

    Oh, come on! They heard she had Vagina Dentata and they were performing a service. Leave these ass clowns alone — it’ll probably save her vaginal cavities down the road.

  41. Tonya Cooley Real World Toothbrush Rape
    Commented on this photo:

    C’mon, man…that outfit TOTALLY screams “I’m begging for a cootbrush!”

  42. snarl

    oh their moms must be so proud.

  43. JJ

    I call bullshit. It’s been 3 years and she’s ran out of “job opportunities”. If she was really raped, on camera, she would have pressed criminal charges. Only a liar sues over rape instead of calling the police.

    • Whatever, douchebag

      She should have pressed charges in Phucket? You think that would have gone anywhere? She didn’t even know right away, witnesses told her after the fact. And it takes time to file a lawsuit. Good lord, but you are fucking dumb. That’s okay, don’t let a silly thing like a complete lack of understanding of how shit works stop you from getting on your high horse, dumbfuck.

  44. Douchebag

    I doubt a lawsuit takes 3 years to file.

  45. Ddd

    Everyone remembers that sweet little tonya also did a softcore porno a few years back, right? Apparently no one is willing to pay to see her vag anymore so now she has to sue people who wouldn’t even touch that filthy thing in the first place. The only part of her story that’s moderately believable is that they raped her with a toothbrush since they obviously didn’t want to actually touch that filthy trap themselves.

  46. forrest gump

    believe it or not: HE IS USING THE DILDO OF LANCE BAS AS A TOOTHBRUSH, folks!!

  47. kara

    so she was passed out then claimed no one told her what happened. then how the fuck does she know what happened?

  48. LJ

    She may have only gotten a copy of the MTV tape a few months ago.

  49. icon7d

    Maybe they were trying to fix her cavity?

    (I’m sorry I couldn’t help it. Rape is bad. Very very bad.)

  50. thespiral

    I hate rape as much as any woman, but you gotta admire the girl for taking one for the team so we now have an excuse to cancel that brain-meltingly retarded piece of shit show. You’re doing God’s work, Tonya.

Leave A Comment